1. Father John Smith 1877-1886
2. Msgr. Michael F. John Cassidy 1886-1933
3. Msgr. John McNamara 1934-1948
4. Msgr. Timothy O'Sullivan 1949-1966
5. Father John Connealy 1967-1969
6. Father Peter F. Dunne 1969-1972
7. Father Martin Conley 1972-1977
8. Father Benedict LaRocque 1977-1982
9. Father Roland Peschel 1982-1989
10. Father Paul Ortmeier 1989-1994
11. Father Richard Reiser 1994-1999
12. Father Mark Filips 1999-

Assistant priests who served at St. Patrick's Parish and were instructors at St. Mary's

1. Rev. P. Brophy
2. Rev. Mugan
3. Rev. J. Delbove
4. Rev. H. Hoheisel
5. Rev. M. F. Sheehan
6. Rev. Joseph Kohler
7. Rev. W. Rehbach
8. Rev. J. Hancik
9. Rev. T. S. Moriarty
10. Rev. A. Brass
11. Rev. T. O'Driscoll
12. Rev. P. A. Flanagan
13. Rev. M. E. Dolan
14. Rev. A. Heimes
15. Rev. J.F. Moore
16. Rev. W. J. Sullivan
17. Rev. E. J. Flanagan
18. Rev. E. M. Gleason
19. Rev. Thomas Carmody
20. Rev. M. Ballon
21. Rev. W. A. Giblin
22. Rev. Joseph Lappan
23. Rev. Joseph Duhamel
24. Rev. Joseph Kohler
25. Rev. J. W. O'Sullivan
26. Rev. M. J. Brady
27. Rev. B. J. Leahy
28. Rev. Walter Flynn
29. Rev. Peter F. Burke
30. Rev. Richard J. Parr
31. Rev. Daniel F. Brick
32. Rev. Raymond J. Lisco
33. Rev. C. J. Werner (Monsignor)
34. Rev. Thomas Hitch
35. Rev. Onak
36. Rev. Thomas Hitch
37. Rev. Kenneth Carl
38. Rev. Robert Duffy
39. Rev. Anthony Milone (Bishop)
40. Rev. Duane Crick
41. Rev. T. Finney
42. Rev. R. Steffen
43. Rev. K. Kucera
44. Rev. George Cagni
45. Rev. Wm. Rucker
46. Rev. James Bushelman
47. Rev. James McCluskey
48. Rev. Frank Dvorak
49. Rev. Don Cleary
50. Rev J. Dillon
51. Rev. Kenneth Potts
52. Rev. Gerald Leise
53. Rev. Ron Wisnewski
54. Rev. Owen Korte
55. Rev. Mike Malloy
56. Rev. Rafeal Librea
57. Rev. Wm. Sanderson
58. Rev. Mark Filips
59. Rev. Steven Gutgsell
60. Rev. Craig Loecker
61. Rev. Edward Scordis
62. Rev. Mark Merkel
63. Rev. Mark Bridgmen